Home MediaLit Moments
MediaLit Moments

Fit-ness is in the Eye of the Beholder

E-mail Print PDF
Many school nursing offices still emphasize body mass index (BMI) as a primary indicator of student health.  Yet body mass index by itself is never a reliable indicator of health, and adolescent students can readily be labeled as “obese” when they may simply be growing unevenly, gaining weight before growing in height, or becoming more muscular in build due to genetic factors or exercise.  Moreover, the practice of measuring BMI can lead schools to focus on individual weight loss rather than the importance of balanced diet and exercise for all students.  Doing so makes it difficult for students who fall outside of the “normal” range to maintain a positive self-image, and can even contribute to the incidence of eating disorders among young people.  

In recognition of National Eating Disorders Awareness Month, we present this MediaLit Moment in which your students will have the chance to reflect on their perceptions regarding weight and physical fitness, and to think more critically about the values and lifestyles embedded in media images of “fit” people.     

Have students analyze their perceptions of a media text that offers an alternative image of fitness.   

AHA! This woman doesn’t look like most of the “fit” people I see in movies or TV, but does that mean she’s “out of shape”?  

Key Question #3:  How might different people understand this message differently?

Core Concept #3:  Different people experience the same media message differently 

Key Question #4:  What values, lifestyles and points of view are represented in, or omitted from, this message?

Core Concept #4:  Media have embedded values and points of view. 

Grade Level:  9-12 

Materials:  Printed image, slide of the same image and slide projector, or computer with broadband access and data projector to display image at the following URL:  http://adsoftheworld.com/files/images/DOVE-Fat-Fit.preview.jpg This image is taken from a 2004 billboard for the Dove Campaign for Real Beauty, and asks viewers whether the model shown on the billboard is “fat” or “fit.”   

Activity:  As an anticipatory set to this lesson, you might want to ask students for their definition of fitness.  What’s most important?  Sticking to a healthy diet?  Being able to run a marathon?  Come up with a loose definition.    
Once you have shown the image, allow some time for students’ spontaneous responses, and simply act as a facilitator for discussion.  When you feel the class is ready, ask:  what inferences (or guesses) can you make regarding this woman’s physical fitness just by looking at the image on the billboard? Can you imagine this woman dancing?  Running?  Skiing?  (or any other activity which requires energy, strength, coordination, etc.) If your students confuse the concepts of thin and fit when discussing fit-ness, call attention to the assumption of thin-ness as a primary indicator of health and how that assumption affects them personally (if time permits, see Extended Activity below).
Next, ask students to write down a list of the “fit” female characters they’ve seen in the media—in movies, on TV, on the Internet, in video games.  What are they like?  What do they do?  You can expand this prompt by giving students the option to add male characters and/or “fat” characters to their list. How does the woman on the billboard compare with the media images of fit people that they see on an everyday basis?  Why do they think the producers of these other media portrayed fit characters in the way that they did?  

Extended Activity:  Assign a project in which students do some research on what constitutes physical fitness. Or consult with a health teacher and distribute materials (or direct students to sources) on physical fitness that helps them understand that weight is just one indicator of health that should be considered in context with many other factors.  Or. . . ask them to interview people they think are fit, and ask them what “staying fit” means to them, and why they believe that is true.

OR:     
Key Question #5:  Why was this message sent?
Core Concept #5:  Most media messages are organized to gain profit and/or power.

Dove took down the billboards when 51% of audiences responded that they thought the model was “fat.”  Why do they think Dove took the billboards down, and why do they think Dove produced this billboard in the first place? If you were in charge of this campaign, would you do anything differently?  You could also ask students to draw or produce their own billboard (well, something that will fit inside the classroom door. . .).   

If you want to broaden the discussion, ask students to visit the Campaign for Real Beauty website  (www.campaignforrealbeauty.com), and ask students why a major beauty products company would decide to create this campaign.     

The Five Core Concepts and Five Key Questions of media literacy were developed as part of the Center for Media Literacy’s MediaLit Kit™ and Questions/TIPS (Q/TIPS)™ framework. Used with permission, © 2002-2010, Center for Media Literacy, http://www.medialit.com

Last Updated ( Thursday, 18 February 2010 16:06 )
 

What Does It Mean To Be Green?

E-mail Print PDF

According to a Cone Consumer Environmental Survey conducted this year, 34% of Americans indicate that they are more likely to buy environmentally responsible products today, and another 44% indicate that their environmental shopping habits have not changed despite the current economic climate (http://www.coneinc.com). Not surprisingly, environmental marketing campaigns have also been on the upswing.

And there is no doubt that a significant number of deceptive (or “greenwashed”) advertisements and product labels have been riding the tide of these campaigns.  Terra Choice Environmental Marketing published a “Sevens Sins of Greenwashing” report this year which asserted that 98% of products reviewed violated at least one of their rules for making legitimate environmental claims (http://sinsofgreenwashing.org).  In fact, this year’s report adds an additional “sin” not included in the 2007 report--“the sin of worshipping false labels,” a practice by which companies give the impression of third party environmental endorsements for their products where no such endorsement exists. 

But enough of the bad news.  The good news is that “green” advertisements and labels provide a great springboard for teaching across nearly all disciplines.  By analyzing these advertisements, students can increase their consumer, health and financial literacy.

In this MediaLit Moment, your high school students will have the chance to consider the moral, social and ecological ramifications of an activity they are becoming familiar with---shaving--against the environmental claims that a major auto maker makes for its cars.    

Have students analyze and evaluate a “green” advertisement’s appeal to them, as well as the message it conveys about their lifestyle choices.

AHA!:  They’re trying to tell me that buying a fuel-efficient car from them is more important than saving resources at home!

Key Question #5:  Why was this message sent?

Core Concept #5:  Most media messages are organized to gain profit and/or power

Key Question #4:  What values, lifestyles and points of view are represented in, or omitted from, this message? 

Core Concept #4:  Media have embedded values and points of view

Grade Level:  10-12

Materials:  computer with high speed internet access, data projector, projection screen, GM E85 (ethanol fuel) car advertisement, accessed at You Tube:   http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Iv9xgHiBPWw  

Activity:  Have students watch the commercial at least a couple of times.  After the first showing, ask students, what makes this commercial funny?  And also ask, what kind of audience do they think GM was trying to target with this ad? (According to our research, this ad aired only on MTV).

After the second showing, ask students about the environmental claims of this commercial.  What is the carmaker trying to say about the corn-based fuel that the car uses (ethanol) and the water students (boys and girls) use to shave?  

Next, ask them how they feel about the fact that the advertisement is trying to persuade them that their personal consumption habits matter less than the decision to invest in a new Chevy vehicle.  Are they embarrassed when they think of how much water they use?  Are they annoyed by the comparison?  Are they “sold” on the product?  Does the advertisement simply make them laugh?  Can they explain why they feel the way they do?    

Extended Activity: 

Key Question #3:  How might different people understand this message differently? 

Core Concept #3:  Different people experience the same media message differently

Ask your students to rate the environmental claims of this commercial.  Are the environmental benefits of driving a Chevy E85 presented in a credible and appropriate way? Did GM “fudge” the facts a little?  Is this ad a good example of greenwashing?   For example, does the ad present an “apples to oranges” comparison that “sounds” right but cannot be readily substantiated?  Also, is ethanol really a “gas friendly” alternative fuel, or are the claims that GM makes about ethanol and their ethanol-compatible vehicles overblown?  Place students in pairs or teams and ask them to prepare presentations based on their research.  Or organize a debate. . .or a forum. 

Here are some sources that you may want to use to prepare study guides, or to assign to students in their entirety: 

Greenwashing

US Federal Trade Commission guides to environmental claims in advertising: http://www.ftc.gov/bcp/grnrule/guides980427.htm

Recent Federal Trade Commission testimony to Congress on attempts to regulate the “virtual tsunami” of recent green advertising: http://www.ftc.gov/os/2009/06/P954501greenmarketing.pdf

Understanding and Preventing Greenwash:  A Business Guide, by BSR and Futerra Associates http://www.bsr.org/reports/Understanding_Preventing_Greenwash.pdf

Consumer Reports evaluations of “green” products at http://www.greenerchoices.org

Terrra Choice 2009 report on greenwashing at http://sinsofgreenwashing.org

The Ethanol Debate

Thermodynamics of the Corn-Ethanol Biofuel Cycle, by Ted Patzek, Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, UC Berkeley http://petroleum.berkeley.edu/papers/patzek/CRPS416-Patzek-Web.pdf

The Debate on Energy and Greenhouse Gas Emissions Impacts of Fuel Ethanol by Michael Wang, Argonne National Laboratories http://www.transportation.anl.gov/pdfs/TA/347.pdf 

“Ethanol Can Contribute to Energy and Environmental Goals,” by Farrell, Plevin, Turner et al., Science magazine, January 27, 2006 (volume 311), pps. 506-508.  Accessible online at:  http://rael.berkeley.edu/EBAMM/FarrellEthanolScience012706.pdf

 

The Five Core Concepts and Five Key Questions of media literacy were developed as part of the Center for Media Literacy’s MediaLit Kit™ and Questions/TIPS (Q/TIPS)™ framework.  Used with permission, © 2002-2009, Center for Media Literacy, http://www.medialit.com

 

Last Updated ( Sunday, 17 January 2010 16:20 )
 

A Crash Course in Marketing

E-mail Print PDF

In this MediaLit Moment, your students will have the chance to explore the differences between social and commercial marketing campaigns for the same product, and also to investigate the motivations driving the organizers of each campaign.    

     

Have students compare and contrast a public safety message about bicycle helmets and an advertisement for a popular helmet brand.

AHA!  The people who made these videos want me to buy a bicycle helmet for very different reasons!       

Key Question #5:  Why is this message being sent?

Core Concept #5:  Most media messages are organized to gain profit and/or power.

Grade Level:  6-8

Materials:  Computer with high speed internet access, data projector, projection screen

Public service announcement from the Brain Injury Association, accessed at: http://www.biami.org/bully.mpeg

Giro bicycle helmet advertisement accessed at:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vTT9tr68V8E

Activity: View the two videos with students.  Start with the public service announcement.  Since this video is only 30 seconds long, you may want to show it two to three times.  What is the message of this video?  Ask students how they feel about the risks of riding a bicycle without a helmet after seeing the announcement.  How high do they believe these risks are now that they’ve seen this PSA?  Next, show the Giro advertisement to students.  Since this video is only 30 seconds long, you may want to show this video two to three times as well.  Ask students questions about the message of this video.  Does the commercial tell viewers that they will be safer if they wear this helmet?   Why--according to the commercial--should they buy a Giro helmet?  How do they feel about buying a Giro helmet after seeing this commercial?   

Ask students questions about technique: Key Question #2:  What creative techniques are used to attract my attention?  Core Concept #2: Messages are constructed using a creative language with its own rules.

How did each video attempt to get and keep their attention?  How did each video attempt to persuade them to buy a helmet?  Next, ask students why each message was sent.  Why do they think the Brain Injury Association decided to produce this PSA?  Why did Giro decide to produce this commercial?  In discussing the public service announcement, you may want to explain that non-profit organizations need to convince people that their organization addresses a serious social problem so that they have a better chance of attracting people and funding to their cause.   

Ask students to write down a list of purposes for each video, and ask them to compare and contrast the answers they wrote down for each.  Do Giro and BIA have any motivations in common?  

Extended Activity:   This activity is adapted from one of the sample 8th grade activities from the Partnership for 21st Century Skills “Science Map,” reviewed elsewhere in this issue.   Ask the students to apply what they’ve learned about the marketing of bicycle helmets to the task of product evaluation.  Now that students have seen videos which encourage them to perceive the benefits of bicycle helmets in different ways, ask them to objectively evaluate the product.                                                                    

Begin with this question:  Why should you buy a helmet?    

Here are some questions for research:  What are the risks of injury for children and adults who ride a bicycle without a helmet?  How effective are bicycle helmets in reducing these risks? If your state requires cyclists to wear helmets, have these laws reduced the number of head injuries among cyclists?  Are some helmets more effective than others in reducing the risk of injury?  If yes, what makes these helmets more effective?  Design?  Materials?  What brand or model of helmet do they recommend?  Why?      

The Five Core Concepts and Five Key Questions of media literacy were developed as part of the Center for Media Literacy’s MediaLit Kit™ and Questions/TIPS (Q/TIPS)™ framework.  Used with permission, © 2002-2009, Center for Media Literacy, http://www.medialit.com

 

 

 

Last Updated ( Friday, 04 December 2009 07:30 )
 

Virtual Science Symposium

E-mail Print PDF

How might the history of science been affected if the great physicists of the early 20th century had been able to take part in transatlantic teleconferences at the touch of a button?  Would their positions have changed about using scientific knowledge to build an atomic weapon? In this MediaLit Moment, your students will have the chance to develop their scientific literacy skills by discussing controversial social issues in which scientific knowledge plays a substantial role.  And they’ll be able to create a digital media  product and use it as a vehicle for collaboration in and out of the classroom.    

Have students take the positions of famous scientists as they discuss controversial social-scientific issues in a moderated cell phone conference

The use of cell phones, in conjunction with a teleconferencing web site, expands the potential circulation of these science symposia almost exponentially.  That expanded circulation can boost student motivation, stimulate further class discussion, and provide a tangible product (an MP3 file of the conference) which can be easily assessed by teachers and students alike.         

AHA!:  Scientists who are famous sometimes use the media to give their opinions on politics as well as science!    

Key Question #4 for Producers:  Have I clearly and consistently framed values, lifestyles and points of view in my content? 

Core Concept #4: Media have embedded values and points of view

Grade Level:  9-12

Materials:  For teacher, computer with high speed internet connection to access FreeConferencePro website; for students, individual cell phones with current coverage subscriptions.

This virtual conference activity is not a complete lesson, but rather an activity based on national science and technology standards.  Please feel free to adapt it to fit a variety of purposes and contexts.  The activity itself has been adapted from Toys to Tools, with permission from the publisher.

Standards:  National Educational Technology Standards for Students--Performance  Indicators for Grades 9-12:  7, 8, 9, 10.   National Science Education Standards:  Science in Personal and Social Perspectives, Content Standard F:  Grades 9-12

Activity/ Lesson Description:  Students in two different schools will participate in joint virtual cell phone conferences concerning topical issues in science.  Topical issues include stem cell research, nutrition, global warming, genetically engineered foods, and cloning, to name a few.  Students will be placed in groups of five, in which two students from one school will be paired with two students from another school; the remaining student (from either school) will be the moderator or host of the conference.  Each student in the group will research and “become” a well-known scientist in a specific field.  The students will take on the scientist’s perspective on the issue and participate in a virtual conference for homework.  The virtual conferences will automatically be saved as an MP3 file with the assistance of FreeConferencePro. 

Process

In Class

1.  Two teachers from different schools in the same or a similar science subject area pair up and decide on the topical issues they want their students to discuss.

2.  Each teacher assigns two students to each agreed-upon controversial topic.

3.  In their groups, the students select current or past scientists who have contributed to a specific controversial scientific topic. 

4.  Students research their particular scientist and the scientist’s perspective on the topic.

5.  The teachers select one additional student to become the moderator or host for the group.  This student records the conference and asks questions to keep the conference flowing.  This student also develops a list of questions for the virtual symposium. 

6.  One of the teachers sets up a FreeConferencePro account.  Here is how:

            A.  Go to FreeConferencePro at http://www.freeconferencepro.com

            B.  Click on  SIGN UP NOW.

            C.  Fill in the appropriate information and click on submit.

            D.  A new screen will appear with the conference access number, the passcode,

                 and the host ID.  Copy down all three of these numbers.  Students will use  

                 the conference phone number and passcode to access the conference from

                 their cell phones.  The host student can use the host ID to start and stop and

                 control the conference.

7.  The teachers give their students the conference phone number and the passcode.  They also give the host students the host ID.

Outside Class      

8. Students in each group select a mutual time to conference for homework.

9.  The host student dials in to the conference phone number, types in the passcode, and presses the asterisk (*) symbol.

10.    The host will then be asked to type in the host ID.  Once the host ID has been entered, the host should select the pound sign (#) and number 9.  This will start the conference recording.

11.  The rest of the students can now dial in to the conference phone number.

12.  Students should type in the passcode followed by the pound sign (#). 

13.  Once all the students in the group are on the conference line, they can begin the conference.

14.  When the conference is done, the students can just hang up. 

Back in Class

15.  For the teachers to listen to and evaluate the conferences (or share them with the rest of the class), they have to log in to the FreeConferencePro portal.  Here is how:

            A.  Log in to FreeConferencePro at http://www.freeconferencepro.com

            B.    Sign in to the portal account.  The portal account shows when conferences were recorded and how long they lasted.

            C.    Click on Recordings. 

            D.    In the Recordings window, teachers can download an MP3 file of the conferences.  There is also an option to listen to recordings over the phone. 

Extensions

  • If you do not have another school or classroom to pair up with, your students can participate with students in other class periods of the same subject that you teach.
  • Teachers can ask an expert scientist from the local community (or anywhere) to participate in the virtual conferences.
  • The virtual conferences can be posted on the class blog or Web page so that other students can listen to them and parents can listen and comment.
  • Teachers can also participate in the conference sessions.
  • Instead of doing the conference sessions all at once, a conference could be conducted about once a month (or at the beginning each new unit, as an introduction for that topic).  Each group of students would be in charge of the conference for only one month (or unit) during the school year. 
The Five Core Concepts and Five Key Questions of media literacy were developed as part of the Center for Media Literacy’s MediaLit Kit™ and Questions/TIPS (Q/TIPS)™ framework.  Used with permission, © 2002-2009, Center for Media Literacy, http://www.medialit.com

 

Last Updated ( Wednesday, 18 November 2009 10:05 )
 

What's in a Map?

E-mail Print PDF

As the authors make clear in Seeing Through Maps (see review in Maps Newsletter, Oct. 2009), people who read maps are audiences, and maps usually have something to “say” to their readers.  For example, a tourist map that shows the locations of downtown businesses says “Shop downtown!”  But how often do people get to read a map that says something they want to hear about themselves or their community?  In this MediaLit Moment, your students will have the chance to create a map that expresses their feelings about the community in which they live, as well as their thoughts about the things in their community that they might like to see change. 

Have your students create a “current use” map of their community

AHA!:  In this map, I’m not just telling people where places are, I’m also telling them about my community! 

Key Question #4 for Producers:  Have I clearly and consistently framed values, lifestyles and points of view in my content? 

Core Concept #4:  Media have embedded values and points of view

Grade:  4+

Materials:  colored markers (we suggest red and blue), and a base map to distribute to students.  The choice of area for the base map depends on your location and the demographics of your student population.  If your school is in a rural location, you may need a map which focuses on a county-wide area.  If your school is located in an urban area, then your map should focus on one or more neighborhoods.  If your students commute from long distances, you may want to make the school the focal point of your map. 

Because the map that your students make will include the public places they go on a daily basis, you should use a base map which gives students a frame of reference by indicating the location of public places and municipal services such as hospitals, fire stations, libraries, schools, etc.  Students will be making sentence-length notes on these maps, so a map which only includes arterial streets may be the best for this activity.  Your local planning agency will probably be the best source for these maps, but you may be able to use Google Maps for this activity.  The base map from Open Street Maps (http://www.openstreetmap.org) may also be useful. 

Size may be the biggest challenge in assembling your materials.  Students should have plenty of room to write on these maps, and this activity is best conducted in groups of 4 or more so that students will be able to easily compare notes.  If possible, print your maps 20” x 20” or larger and post them on the walls of your classroom. 

Activity: 

First, ask the class how people use maps, especially city maps.  What kind of information do people usually get from these maps?    

Introduce the base maps that students will be using for this activity.  These are the kinds of maps that you’ve just been talking about.  Let them know that they’re going to create a “user” map that will help make the original map better.  To help students orient themselves, and to help them understand the kind of information they will add to the maps, ask them to circle one or more of the public places already printed on the map with pencil or plain ink and check for understanding.    

Next, ask your students to mark the locations of public places they use everyday -- streets, bus stops, malls, businesses, parks, playgrounds, supermarkets.  Ask them to mark these in pencil or plain ink.  Ask them to draw them in if they don’t already appear on the map.  Students do not need to make an exhaustive list.        

Next, ask your students to locate and mark one or two of their favorite public places with a blue marker, and to write a sentence at each marking which explains why this is one of their favorite places.  Is there something they like to buy there?  Is it a place with a lot of room to play?  Finally, ask your students to locate and mark one or two public areas that they have some problem with.  Is it a place where they avoid riding their bikes?  Is it part of their school playground that should have another yard duty? Is it a barrier to access to part of their favorite park?  A library with internet stations that are always full? Ask them to mark the locations with a red marker, and to write one sentence which describes the problem. 

When students have finished, ask your students questions to help them understand the kind of map they’ve created.  Is the information in their “favorites” and “problems” markings different in some way from the service information on the base map?  How is it different?

Students are ready for the AHA! (or turning point) of this lesson once they begin to understand that they’ve added information that is evaluative as well as factual.  At that point you can let students know how important their opinions really are.  Their maps of public places don’t just document their personal preferences. Their maps are an invaluable source of information to other community members (For example, a librarian would definitely want to know about students’ frustration with the relative lack of internet access.  Many store owners would want to know whether students felt welcome at their store).  

As you lead this discussion, keep a list of the people who might want to see their maps, and use this as a potential list of real-world contacts for future lessons.

The Five Core Concepts and Five Key Questions of media literacy were developed as part of the Center for Media Literacy’s MediaLit Kit™ and Questions/TIPS (Q/TIPS)™ framework.  Used with permission, © 2002-2009, Center for Media Literacy, http://www.medialit.com
Last Updated ( Thursday, 01 October 2009 14:00 )
 


Page 18 of 20
Previous Issues:

 21st century skills
 a day in the life of a media literacy educator
 a year in review 2014
 a year in review december 2012
 advertising consumer debt and media literacy
 anytime anywhere learning
 big data
 body image and media literacy
 bots terrorism and media literacy
 building a strong foundation
 call to action
 cell phones as learning tools
 change management in schools
 children and media literacy part 2
 children and media literacy
 citizen journalism
 citizenship in the digital age part 2
 citizenship in the digital age
 cml media literacy trilogy
 comics and media literacy
 community media
 confirmation bias and media literacy
 criteria for media literacy instruction
 crowdfunding and media literacy
 data representation and media literacy
 digital britain
 documentary film and media literacy
 education and creative economy
 education creative economy australia
 empowerment theory practice activism
 esl and media literacy
 fair use for media literacy
 faith and media literacy
 frameworks for inquiry
 gender representation media
 global citizenship media literacy
 global education
 globalization
 heuristics nudge theory and the internet of things
 history of media literacy
 leadership elizabeth thoman
 len masterman and the big ideas of media literacy
 libraries museums and informal learning
 maps and media literacy
 media and body image
 media and information literacy
 media and information literacy part 2
 media deconstruction as essential learning skill
 media literacy computational thinking
 media literacy risk assessment
 media literacy and 21st century skills
 media literacy and arts education
 media literacy and common core
 media literacy and human rights
 media literacy and masculinity
 media literacy and media construction
 media literacy and nutrition
 media literacy and personal data management
 media literacy and pharmaceutical advertising
 media literacy and science
 media literacy and student empowerment
 media literacy and the environment
 media literacy and video games
 media literacy early childhood education
 media literacy for grown ups
 media literacy in the community
 media literacy pioneers
 media literacy policy and legislation
 media morals and empowerment
 media representation lgbtq
 media violence and media relationships
 media violence
 monsters and media literacy
 new curriculum and media literacy
 online privacy and media literacy
 online safety
 parents and media literacy
 participation in what
 professional development for media literacy
 propaganda and media literacy
 reality tv and media literacy
 redefining school communities
 research media literacy
 responding to racism and stereotypes in media
 sexism in media
 social networking
 sports and media literacy
 systems thinking and media literacy
 teaching healthy skepticism
 television and media literacy
 the mediated city and the public
 the role of journalism in society
 trust through technology
 us department of education
 voices of media literacy
 what media literacy is and is not
 whats in a name
 where are we now institutionalizing media literacy

CONNECTIONS